Close

Stock Lending and Stock Yield Enhancement: Benefits, Risks, and Key Differences in WealthSimple and IBKR

Investing is not just about buying and holding stocks; there are ways to maximize the earning potential of your portfolio. One such strategy is stock lending, also referred to as Stock Yield Enhancement. While it can boost your returns, it comes with risks that need to be carefully considered. In this blog, we’ll break down what stock lending is, its benefits and risks, and explore how it works in two popular platforms: WealthSimple and Interactive Brokers (IBKR).

What Is Stock Lending?

Stock lending, or securities lending, involves lending your shares to other investors or institutions, typically for short selling. In return, you earn a fee from the borrower. The borrower provides collateral, often in the form of cash or other securities, to minimize the lender’s risk. This practice is often used by short sellers who aim to profit from declining stock prices by selling borrowed shares and repurchasing them later at a lower price.

Benefits of Stock Lending

  1. Earn Passive Income: By lending your stocks, you earn lending fees, which can be an additional source of income.
  2. No Impact on Portfolio Value: Your stock holdings remain in your account, and you continue to benefit from price appreciation and dividends (though dividends may be paid as compensation in certain cases).
  3. Leverage Idle Assets: Instead of letting your stocks sit idle, stock lending allows you to put them to work.

Risks of Stock Lending

  1. Counterparty Risk: If the borrower defaults, the collateral provided may not fully cover the loss.
  2. Reduced Voting Rights: When you lend your shares, you typically lose your voting rights on those shares.
  3. Tax Implications: Dividends paid during the lending period may be treated differently for tax purposes, depending on the jurisdiction.
  4. Market Risk: The value of the stock can decline during the lending period, affecting your portfolio.

Stock Lending with Wealthsimple

WealthSimple offers a stock lending program called the Stock Lending Program, available only for Tax-Free Savings Accounts (TFSA) and margin accounts. Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) and other registered accounts are excluded. Here’s how it works:

  • WealthSimple lends out your eligible securities to institutional borrowers.
  • You earn a portion of the income generated from the lending activity.
  • Wealthsimple manages the process, including borrower vetting and securing collateral.

Benefits in WealthSimple:

  • Simple and hands-off: WealthSimple handles all the logistics.
  • No additional fees for participating.

Risks in Wealthsimple:

  • Loss of voting rights while shares are lent.
  • Lack of control over which stocks are lent.

Stock Lending with Interactive Brokers (IBKR)

Interactive Brokers (IBKR) also offers a stock lending program, but it is only available for margin accounts. Unlike Wealthsimple, you cannot use this feature in tax-advantaged accounts such as TFSAs or RRSPs. Here’s how it works:

  • IBKR’s Stock Yield Enhancement Program (SYEP) allows you to lend fully paid shares or shares purchased on margin to borrowers.
  • You earn 50% of the income generated from the lending, while IBKR retains the other half.

Benefits in IBKR:

  • Transparent reporting: IBKR provides detailed information about lending fees and activity.
  • Wide range of eligible securities.

Risks in IBKR:

  • Higher counterparty risk since IBKR’s program typically deals with institutional borrowers.
  • Complex fee structures compared to WealthSimple.

Key Differences Between Wealthsimple and IBKR

FeatureWealthsimpleInteractive Brokers (IBKR)
Eligible AccountsTFSA, MarginMargin Only
Availability in RRSPNot AvailableNot Available
Lending Fee SplitNot Disclosed50% Lender, 50% IBKR
ManagementFully ManagedMore Control and Transparency
Dividend TreatmentMay Be CompensatedMay Be Compensated
Borrower TypeInstitutionalInstitutional
Product Eligible for LendingStocks, ETFsStocks, ETFs

Protection in Canada (CDIC and CIPF)

CDIC protects bank accounts (like your cash account) up to $100,000. (Note: WealthSimple says they hold the cash in multiple accounts to give you protection up to $1,000,000 instead, take that for what it’s worth.)

CIPF protects your investment accounts (Up to $1,000,000 for the combination of TFSA, non-registered. and crypto accounts and another $1,000,000 for the combination of all RRSP/RRIF/RLIF/LIRA accounts, and another $1,000,000 for RESP).

Final Thoughts

Stock lending can be a great way to enhance your portfolio’s returns, but it’s not without risks. WealthSimple’s hands-off approach makes it ideal for beginner investors looking for simplicity, while Interactive Brokers’ detailed reporting and control are better suited for experienced investors.

Before participating, ensure you understand the program’s terms and risks on your chosen platform. Additionally, consider how losing voting rights and potential tax implications may affect your investment strategy. By weighing the benefits and risks, you can decide whether stock lending aligns with your financial goals.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *